Parts 7 and 8 of the Civil Procedure Rules both provide the procedure for starting a claim in court, but they are different. In this article, Hamshaw explains the difference and when they are used.
What’s the Difference?
Part 7 is the normal, default procedure for civil claims. It is generally used where the court needs to resolve a substantial dispute about what happened.
Part 8 is available where the court can resolve the dispute between the parties without having to investigate and decide any substantial factual disputes.
For example, in a construction case, a claim about who caused a delay will usually proceed under Part 7 because there will be lots of facts in dispute: what happened, when, why, and whose fault.
However, a claim about the correct way to interpret an extension of time clause could be suitable for Part 8, because it’s centrally a question of contractual interpretation and there are unlikely to be any matters of fact in dispute which influence how the contract should be interpreted.
A Part 8 claim might also be suitable where the parties disagree on the facts, but are willing to allow the court to decide a dispute based on certain agreed or assumed facts. In other words, sometimes parties to construction disputes ask the court to decide a point and in doing so to assume certain facts relevant to that point are true.
As a general rule of thumb, if a claim is going to need live evidence from witnesses (and cross-examination), then it’s unlikely to be suitable for the Part 8 procedure.
What Happens in a Part 7 Claim?
After issuing the claim form, the claimant sets out its case in its particulars of claim. The defendant then serves a defence explaining which allegations it admits, and which it disputes (and why).
A defendant may also bring a counterclaim. For example, a contractor might sue for an unpaid balance and the employer might counterclaim for the cost of putting defects right.
The court then gives directions for the steps needed to resolve the dispute. These may include disclosure of documents, exchange of witness statements and expert evidence, and a trial.
The court can also give summary judgment on a Part 7 claim where the relevant test is met. An application to enforce an adjudicator’s decision is a common construction example of a Part 7 claim dealt with by summary judgment.
What Happens in a Part 8 Claim?
In a Part 8 claim, the claimant sets out the question it wants the court to decide, or the remedy it seeks, in the claim form itself. It files its written evidence with the claim form and serves both together.
The defendant does not then serve a defence. Instead, it states whether it contests the claim in its acknowledgment of service and usually files any written evidence at the same time.
The claimant can then serve evidence in reply, if it wants to.
A defendant who wants to bring a counterclaim needs the court’s permission first.
Because the parties put their evidence before the court at the outset, the court can often decide the claim at a hearing on the written evidence and legal arguments, but it can still give directions for oral evidence or cross-examination if needed.
If the defendant raises a substantial dispute of fact which makes Part 8 unsuitable, it must explain why in its acknowledgment of service. The court can then direct that the claim continues under Part 7.
Is Part 8 Quicker or Cheaper?
It can be, but isn’t always.
A question that can be decided from the contract and a small set of agreed documents may need fewer procedural steps and a shorter hearing, but the cost still depends on the work involved. A difficult question of interpretation can require substantial written and oral argument.
The crucial step is taken before the claim is issued. Obtaining good advice as to what is actually in dispute, and how it could be framed as a question to the court which does not require contested facts to be established, is the key to ensuring that a Part 8 claim is available and the dispute is resolved faster and with less cost.
Adjudication Enforcement: Part 7 or Part 8?
If the adjudicator has ordered payment, and the losing party refuses to pay, the usual route is to issue a Part 7 claim in the Technology and Construction Court whilst simultaneously applying for summary judgment. The court can enforce the decision without trying the underlying dispute about the work or the amount due.
A party may sometimes use Part 8 to obtain a ruling on a short, self-contained point arising from the adjudication where doing so could defeat the application to enforce.
Whether the court will hear it alongside enforcement is a separate question. The court will do so where it is appropriate and convenient, but the point raised in the Part 8 proceedings must be capable of resolution with minimal factual enquiry and without extensive legal arguments.
For example, if an adjudicator awards Party A £1m but does so on the basis of a notice having been served on a particular date, and the adjudicator is wrong about that date, then Party B might bring a Part 8 claim concerning the contractual interpretation of the correct date. If Party B succeeds in establishing that the date relied on by the adjudicator is not the date provided for by the contract, with the consequence that the £1m should not have been awarded to Party A, then Party B might succeed in defeating Party A’s attempts to enforce the decision.
However, merely issuing a Part 8 claim does not of itself suspend the obligation to comply with the adjudicator’s decision.
If you would like help understanding whether a Part 7 or Part 8 claim is appropriate, contact Hamshaw today.
These articles are provided for general information only. They are intended to assist with a basic understanding of common topics, which a client can read before consulting a solicitor about the specifics of their case. They are not a substitute for, and should not be relied upon as, legal advice. The law changes regularly, and the information contained in these articles is not updated to account for any changes.